Carthage · NY · United States
Captain Ben Roggie orchestrates a year-round fishing symphony across Lake Ontario and its tributaries — from spring walleye runs to winter ice fishing — turning seasonal transitions into consistent trophy opportunities.

At a Glance
Henderson Harbor occupies a sheltered pocket on the New York side of Lake Ontario's eastern basin, roughly 40 miles northeast of Syracuse and just west of the Thousand Islands. The harbor itself is shallow and weed-choked—ideal nursery water for smallmouth bass and walleye—but the real fishing happens in the adjacent open lake, where depths drop quickly to 80+ feet. This transition zone, particularly the shelf between 40 and 60 feet, concentrates fish seasonally and makes Henderson a reliable charter destination year-round. Walleye dominate spring and fall, when cool water pushes them into the mid-depth band; guides work live bait and jigging presentations along the breakline, often marking suspended schools on electronics. Smallmouth bass peak in early summer and again in September, with fish holding on rocky structure and weed edges in 15–40 feet. The harbor's protected waters also hold largemouth and panfish, making it a fallback option on rough-water days. Lake Ontario's water levels fluctuate with dam releases upstream, affecting access and fish location; most charters monitor the Oswego gauge and adjust presentations accordingly. The harbor itself offers easy launch and mooring, and the nearby village provides basic services. Weather on the open lake can turn quickly—typical of the Great Lakes—so most trips run spring through October, with June and September offering the most consistent conditions and the heaviest fish populations.
Location
Carthage, NY, United States
Approximate location
Species & Seasons
Methods
My guiding year is a dynamic dance with the seasons, offering a diverse angling experience across Lake Ontario and its tributaries. Spring kicks off with the ice melt, bringing opportunities for Brown Trout and Walleye in April and May. As the weather warms, we transition to targeting a wider array of species in Lake Ontario, from the deep-water Lake Trout and Salmon in the summer months to the exciting Walleye and Smallmouth Bass action in the bays. For those who prefer a more intimate casting experience, the Black and Indian Rivers come alive from May through September, offering a chance to pursue Walleye, Pike, Bass, and panfish using both live bait and artificial lures. When winter blankets the region, I shift focus to the hardwater, providing fully guided ice fishing trips for Northern Pike, Walleye, Perch, and Crappie, ensuring a successful and comfortable experience on the ice from January through March.
This profile is growing — details are confirmed directly with the lodge.
Exclusive Offers
Direct Booking
No Booking Fees
Book directly with the lodge
VOIAGE Exclusive Offer
Coming Soon
Reserved for the Voiage community